Showing posts with label skepticality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label skepticality. Show all posts

11.09.2015

dimland radio 11-7-15 show notes

A Little Detour...

I hadn't planned on it, but something sent me down a different track of thought at the top of the show. I reminisced about the old days of going to Paul Bunyan Land in Brainerd, MN. I talked about how, to a child, the park was very impressive, but when Amy and I went in 2002 or so, the park had lost much of its luster and was much more modest than I remembered.
 
Paul was still impressive though.
 
The park closed down at the end of that season that Amy and I visited. However, Paul and much of the other "attractions" of the park moved down the road a piece to join up with Pioneer Village. Amy and I brought our son Hayden there for his birthday just a few years ago. Paul's display was redone and looked much better.
 
Paul from the olden days.  
The more recent Paul.
Tainted Halloween Candy?
 
It seems each year we hear about tainted Halloween candy. Tainted either by drugs or razor blades or pins and needles. And each year, many of the claims turn out to not be true.
 
This year was no exception. (From Snopes.) There was even an untrue claim of needles in candy bars from Brainerd, MN! Ahhh! That story may have been what sent me on the unplanned talk about Paul Bunyan Land.
 
The mind is a terrible thing.
 
Pedantic Moment: Character With Asperger's On Law & Order: Criminal Intent
 
Not exactly a timely topic, but I had seen an episode of Law & Order: Criminal Intent the other night that featured a character with Asperger's Syndrome. Asperger's is on the autism spectrum and is considered to be on the high functioning end.

The character barely functioned socially. I figured he was a half a step up the scale from Dustin Hoffman's Raymond from Rain Man. This guy was very damned awkward socially, which is why I had such a hard time believing he had been married and had sired two kids!

His wife divorced him to marry one of the partners of the law firm at which she worked as a paralegal. We never see the ex-wife or the fellow she moved on with, but I figure she must have had something on the ball to hook up with a rich, powerful lawyer. So, how is it she was ever attracted to such a neurotic, tick-laden, frightened, pattern obsessed, socially inept man as Wally Stevens?

Also, a point made in the show was that Stevens was never diagnosed, so he went through life that way. He had never gone to a doctor ever in his life? Maybe they wouldn't have tagged him with Asperger's, a recently defined condition at the time; but surely any medical doctor worth his salt would have noted something was odd and refer him to a proper medical authority.

Yes, I know. I should repeat to myself, "It's just a show, I should really just relax."
 
What Are The Odds...
 
...That my name would be mentioned on the Skepticality podcast during their The Odds Must Be Crazy segment? Well, pretty good since I did send them a story.
 
I was working my night job and listening to Skepticality when I heard my name and story. I think I jumped a little as I didn't expect to hear John Rael say my name.
 
Very cool!
 
Vitriol From The Left Is Still Vitriol
  
A frequent topic on my show it seems, most of my Facebook friend are politically left, so I see a lot of pro-Democrat and liberal issues stories and memes. I also see a fair amount of vitriol hurled at Republicans and conservatives.
 
Recently, a FB friend was completely baffled that Gov. Chris Christie, a Republican, could be some charitable in his comments about people suffering from drug addiction. My friend couldn't wrap his head around a GOP member having empathy. He posted a link to a Huffington Post story and asked how sometimes "Repiglicans" can break with their usual 'greedy, vile asshole" ways and have some compassion.
 
I gave him an answer:
 
Because, as difficult as it is for some to believe (those who might use terms such as Repiglicans, for example) people we disagree with politically are just as human as we are. They are just as capable of compassion and empathy. But, as humans, we have a tendency to adopt the "us versus them" mentality. The out group isn't us. They should be shunned, ridiclued, dehumanized because they aren't part of our group.
 
Racists tend to do this. Sexists tend to do this. Religious groups against other religious groups tend to do this. The nonreligious against the religious and vice versa tend to do this. It's part of human nature.
 
But, as Rosie said to Charlie in The African Queen, "Nature, Mr. Allnut, is what we are put in this world to rise above."
 
I see this kind of uncharitable attitude toward the political out group daily all through my FB feed. Coming from both sides of the political aisle; however, since most of my FB friends are on the left, I tend to see more ugliness coming from that direction. Which is disappointing as it's the left who seem to pride themselves on appreciating nuance. It was the left that criticized Pres. George W Bush because he didn't do nuance.
 
Well, from what I see on a daily basis, some (I won't say all because I won't play the "us versus them" game) of my friends on the left don't do nuance either. At least when it comes to Repiglicans.
 
I don't know if my message got through.
 

Movie Recommendations: Blackthorn (2011)

Magnolia Pictures
 
An very good Western that is currently streaming on Netflix. It stars Sam Shepard as James Blackthorn, an aging breeder of horses who lives quietly in Bolivia. But, he does have a past. He is, in actuality, the notorious Butch Cassidy and contrary to what the world believes his is quite alive.

Set in the 1920s, some 27 years after Butch was supposed to have died, Blackthorn learns of the death of an old love and decides it's time to return to America.

The trip doesn't go according to plan...
 
Music heard on the show...

Dimland Radio opening theme song: 'Ram' by The Yoleus 
First ad break bumpers: 'Spy World' by Wall of Voodoo & 'This World Over' by XTC
Second ad break bumpers: 'Spirits In The Material World' by The Police &  'New World Man' By Rush
Closing song: 'Angler's Treble Hook' by $5 Fiddle

That's it! See you next Saturday night for Dimland Radio 11 Central, midnight Eastern on www.ztalkradio.com you can also download my show from the z talk show archives page. You can email your questions and comments to drdim@dimland.com
 
You can also go to my CafePress store and buy stuff with my artwork on it and have me do a portrait for you if you like. Find out more here and here.

8.25.2015

everybody got a gris gris

Years ago, on Showtime's Penn & Teller Bullshit, Penn introduced me to the concept of a gris gris (pronounced gree gree). I'd never heard the term before. It refers to an idea that a person so wants to believe in that it may be next to impossible to get them to accept the idea is wrong. It was on the show demonstrating how recycling is bullshit that Penn talked about the gris gris and how everybody got one.

(Clarification 8/26/15: It was pointed out to me that a gris gris is a "talisman, a physical object." This is true, if a minor quibble. The definition I lay out in the previous paragraph was from my memory of the show I mention. I have re-watched the program and what Penn says is as follows:

"A gris gris is a voodoo amulet, something you carry or wear to bring good luck and ward off bad vibes. We have a saying around Bullshit: Everybody got a gris gris. What we mean by that is everyone believes in some crazy thing they just can't quite give up yet."

It appears my memory was pretty good.)

As you may be aware, Penn has lost a lot of weight in a very short time. 105 pounds in about three to four months, to be somewhat close to exact. He and his co-hosts of his podcast Penn's Sunday School had all gotten involved with trainer Ray Cronise and, with Cronise's strict assistance, they all lost a tremendous amount of weight in a very short amount of time.
Thin Penn. From People Magazine.
In fact, Penn's next book will be, in large part, about this miracle weight loss and he recently had Ray Cronise as a guest on the podcast to discuss this amazing feat. My skeptical red flag kept waving as Cronise kept referring to one source as the innovator of this weight loss program. (Penn calls it a cult.) He kept talking about a Dr. Fuhrman and his book "Eat To Live".

Now, one source for a weight loss program might be perfectly fine, but my red flag kept waving as I was reminded of the interview of cartoonist Neal Adams on The Skeptics' Guide to the Universe​. I forget the name, but Adams kept justifying his crackpot ideas (e.g. a hollow and expanding earth) to one specific scientist. A scientist who Adams believes has proven virtually all science disciplines to be wrong.

So, just today Derek Colanduno, host of Skepticality, linked to a blog taking Dr. Fuhrman to task on his seemingly crackpot ideas. Derek cryptically voiced his disappointment in a "prominent, well-known skeptic" who has bought into this "nonsense." Judging by what I've written so far, I'm certain you can guess to whom I think Derek is referring. But, I could be wrong.

Here's the blog post that Derek shared. It's written by Adele Hite. Hite is a registered dietitian who holds a Masters in Public Health from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. In her post, she demonstrates how Fuhrman is wrong as she explains essentially that eating like giraffes, elephants, and gorillas makes sense... if you are a giraffe, an elephant, or a gorilla. (Kind of reminds me of when I heard someone say that socialism works just fine, if you're an ant. But that's politics, so I won't mention it.) She also shoots down the idea the broccoli has more protein than steak, explains how it's the essential amino acids we get from protein that we need in our diet, and that gorillas eat their own poop. (mmmmhhmm!)

Her post is a couple years old, so the information may have changed as science learns new things, but to this layperson (I'm also a cartoonist, but nearly as good as Neal Adams) what Hite has written and the sites she links to make sense. Penn's amazing weight loss appears to be based on quackery. Sure, he's lost the weight, but is he getting what his body needs?

To be fair to Penn, he has always been more than willing to admit when he's wrong. He can change his mind when given good evidence on which to base that change. And he would probably have no problem admitting this just might be his gris gris.

After all, everybody got one.

5.30.2010

dimland radio 5-29-10 show notes


Talking Twins

My friend, Dave, and I went to see our first MN Twins game Saturday at their new ballpark. Very cool. Dave's friends have season tickets and they gave him their tickets and he asked me to go with him. Awwww. And the Twins won!

Behind Blue Eyes Part 2

On the May 22nd edition of Dimland Radio I spoke extensively on my thoughts about The Who and Pete Townshend, paying particular attention to Pete's 2003 arrest on charges of child porn. After that show, the aforementioned Dave said that I missed an opportunity to cast my skeptical gaze on the media, how they report a story and how the people remember those stories. The news media covers a story big at first with sensationalism, but then don't give it the same emphasis when the story turns out to be more mundane.

Townshend's arrest story was all sensations at first, juicy and lurid, but when the investigation had been completed and Townshend had been essentially cleared of all charges, the media reported it almost as an afterthought. That kind of reporting leads the public in general to mainly remembering the opening salvo and forgetting the wrap up. This phenomenon leaves the public thinking ill of Pete and he doesn't deserve it.

To be fair, Pete Townshend has been fairly rehabilitated in the public eye. If he hadn't the 15 different versions of the TV show CSI wouldn't be using Who songs for their themes and The Who wouldn't have been booked to play the last Superbowl's halftime.

RIP Martin Gardner

I talked about the loss of Martin Gardner at the age of 95. He was a founding member of CSICOP (now CSI) and a leading light in the skeptical movement. His contributions were many, most notable was his 1952 book 'Fads & Fallacies in the Name of Science'.

Read more about him here, here and here.


I also took this opportunity to talk about the mistaken notion that celebrities die in threes. What makes someone a celebrity? How close together do the deaths need to be to be clustered? And so on.

My new friend in skepticism

Through my listening to the excellent podcast, Skepticality, I became aware of Chris Brown. Chris is a skeptic whose website is www.skepticsinthepub.net. At his site, he promotes other podcasts, blogs and events of a skeptical nature. I wrote to him about Dimland Radio. He wrote back and we've been FaceBook instant messaging back and forth for quite some time now. Chris will be a guest on my show once we can work out a schedule.

Chris's 10 year-old son, Ethan, has quite an impressive ability with math. Here's the YouTube video that Chris would love to see go viral. Let's help me out, shall we?

Awareness Tests

Chris Brown had me check out a couple YouTube videos that really demonstrate what poor observers we human beings can be. We just aren't that good. We stink! We're awful! Lousy! Crappy!! Almost worthless!!

Take the test here and here.


Jonny Quest

I finished up the show talking about how much I like the original Jonny Quest animated TV series. It was great. I liked the art, the characters (Ok, Bandit got a little annoying), the creatures and villains, the music and, most of all, I liked the fact that people died on the show. Pretty blood thirsty, eh?

Music heard on the show...

Dimland Radio opening theme song: 'Ahead' by Wire
First ad break bumpers: 'Town Called Malice' by The Jam & 'Come Again' by Au Pairs
Second ad break bumpers: 'Age Of Consent' by New Order & 'The Mayor Of Simpleton' by XTC
Closing song: 'Angler's Treble Hook' by $5 Fiddle

That's it! See you next Saturday night for Dimland Radio 11 Central, midnight Eastern on www.ztalkradio.com You can also download my show from the Z Talk On Demand page. You can email your questions and comments to drdim@dimland.com